StreetAlpha
Breadth & Sentiment
S&P 500 Market Bottom Monitor
Breadth & Sentiment Dashboard
March 27, 2026 · SPY $634.09 · ✓ All 5 indicators directly filtered · 124 analogs · 2007–2026
Overall Signal
CAUTION
Fear · Not Capitulation
✓ DIRECT DATA FILTER: Probabilities derived from 107 historical periods where ALL FIVE matched simultaneously: $S5TW 21–51, $S5FI 9–39, $S5TH 27–67, VIX 17–37 at 1.05–2.5× its 20-day avg, SPY drawdown -14.5% to -1.5%. SPY · VIX · $S5TW · $S5FI · $S5TH daily · Jan 2007–2026.
Bottom Confirmed
NO
Capitulation
PARTIAL
Prob. Holds Here
40.2%
All 5 indicators
Median Worst Touch
-4.8%
60-day window
Tail Risk (P10)
-12.35%
SPY ~$570
▸ SPY Price Targets (from $650.34)
$631
-3%
P50 worst
$618
-5%
$605
-7%
$587
-9.7%
P25 worst
$570
-12.35%
P10 worst
$553
-15%
Bear line
Breadth & Sentiment Indicators
$S5TW

$S5TW measures the percentage of S&P 500 stocks currently trading above their 20-day moving average — a short-term breadth gauge.

When most stocks are below their 20-day MA, the market is broadly oversold on a near-term basis, not just dragged down by a few mega-caps. Below 20% indicates widespread short-term weakness. Below 10% is historically rare and marks extreme near-term capitulation.

In the 5-way analog filter, this is the primary trigger: the 15–38 range simultaneously with the other four conditions produced matched historical episodes since 2007.

% Above 20-Day MA
35.78% +17.89%
0⚠ 20⛔ 10100

Directly used in 5-way analog filter. Measures near-term breadth momentum.

$S5FI

$S5FI measures the percentage of S&P 500 stocks trading above their 50-day moving average — an intermediate-term breadth indicator reflecting trend damage built up over several weeks.

When $S5FI drops below 30%, the majority of S&P 500 stocks have broken their intermediate uptrend. Below 20% is the historically stressed zone where analog matches cluster around prior correction lows.

Unlike $S5TW, $S5FI is slower to recover — a divergence where $S5TW recovers but $S5FI lags signals a weak, narrow bounce rather than a true breadth thrust.

% Above 50-Day MA
24.05% +4.57%
0⚠ 20⛔ 10100

Directly used in 5-way analog filter. Below 20% = oversold.

$S5TH

$S5TH measures the percentage of S&P 500 stocks trading above their 200-day moving average — the classic long-term trend filter and the slowest-moving of the three breadth indicators.

True bear market bottoms (2009, 2020) saw $S5TH collapse to 10–20%. Corrections within bull markets typically trough in the 25–40% range. Above 50% means more than half the index is still in long-term uptrends — consistent with a correction, not a structural bear.

Adding $S5TH to the analog filter expands the 'deeper correction' bucket: episodes where all five conditions matched but $S5TH stayed elevated tended to resolve either quickly or with a meaningful secondary leg down — the bimodal distribution.

% Above 200-Day MA
47.31% +4.77%
0⚠ 30⛔ 20100

Directly used in 5-way analog filter. Bear market bottoms typically require <25%.

VIX

The VIX (CBOE Volatility Index) measures the market's expectation of 30-day S&P 500 volatility, derived from options pricing. Rising VIX means options traders are paying up for protection — the 'fear gauge.'

The analog filter uses VIX in two ways: (1) absolute level in range, and (2) VIX elevated vs. its own 20-day average (ratio 1.05–2.5×), ensuring we're capturing genuine fear episodes, not mild chop.

VIX 30 is the key watch level — sustained closes above 30 are associated with panic selling and often precede sharp recoveries. VIX 40+ marks true capitulation (COVID March 2020, GFC 2008). The VIX Spike Risk panel quantifies the historical probability of each threshold being hit in the next 20 trading days.

CBOE Volatility Index
25.25 -4.8
0⚠ 30⛔ 4060

Directly used in 5-way filter. VIX >35 = watch level. VIX >40 = capitulation zone.

CNN F&G

CNN's Fear & Greed Index is a composite of 7 market sentiment indicators: S&P 500 momentum, stock price strength, breadth, put/call ratio, junk bond demand, market volatility (VIX), and safe haven demand.

Each component is scored 0–100 and equally weighted. Scores below 20 (Extreme Fear) have historically coincided with major market lows including March 2020 and October 2022.

This index is not used directly in the 5-way analog filter but serves as a confirmation signal — when breadth indicators and CNN F&G are simultaneously depressed, the forward return distribution shifts more favorably. Data is fetched live from alternative.me which mirrors the CNN index daily.

Fear & Greed Index
8 -3
0⚠ 20⛔ 15100

Composite of 7 sentiment signals. <20 = Extreme Fear. Strong historical contrarian buy zone.

AAII Bears

The AAII (American Association of Individual Investors) Sentiment Survey polls individual investors weekly: Bullish, Neutral, or Bearish on the stock market over the next 6 months. Results are published every Thursday.

This dashboard tracks the Bearish reading as a contrarian signal — when 'everyone' is already bearish, much of the selling pressure has been exhausted. The long-run average bearish reading is ~31%. Readings above 50% are historically unusual.

Prior 50%+ bearish episodes include bottoms in 2009, 2022, and several correction lows. However, sentiment can stay elevated for weeks before the market turns — it is confirmatory, not a precise timing tool. Note: AAII surveys retail investors, not institutions.

AAII Bearish Sentiment
49.8% -17.7%
0⚠ 50⛔ 6080

>50% bearish has historically been a contrarian bullish signal. Elevated at 49.8% — approaching contrarian territory.

Oversold threshold
Extreme / capitulation
Downside Probability Scenarios
Max further SPY drawdown · next 60 trading days · 107 direct analogs · 2007–2026
Holds / Bounces Here < 3% further down SPY > $656
40%
Most likely single outcome. Majority of true analogs saw max further drawdown under 3%.
📊 n=233 · ALL 5 indicators directly filtered · 60-day max drawdown · 2007–2026
60d median: +4.10%
Modest Extension 3–7% further down SPY $629–$656
16%
Outcomes are more bimodal — the middle bucket is compressed by adding breadth filters.
📊 Analogs: Oct 2014, Jun 2016, Aug 2019, Oct 2023
20d median: +2.09%
Deeper Correction 7–15% further down SPY $575–$629
37%
Today's breadth setup has deeper correction history. Adding breadth filters expanded this bucket.
📊 Analogs: Jun 2011, Jul 2015, Oct 2018, Apr 2022, Mar 2025
P10 worst touch: -13.0%
Bear Market > 15% further down SPY < $575
6%
Requires exogenous macro shock or policy error.
📊 Key analogs: Feb 2020 (COVID −31%), Oct 2018 (−15%)
Fat tail — black swan required
▸ Forward Return Distributions from Analog Entry Points
HorizonMeanMedianP10 DownsideP90 Upside% PositiveWorst EverBest Ever
5-Day -0.15% +0.1% -3.94% +3.66%
50.5%
-7.65%
Jul 2011
+5.61%
Jun 2011
10-Day +0.12% +0.76% -5.63% +4.67%
56.1%
-14.95%
Feb 2020
+8.01%
Mar 2022
20-Day +1.31% +2.63% -5.38% +6.5%
70.2%
-30.85%
Feb 2020
+10.36%
Oct 2023
60-Day +2.21% +4.44% -8.31% +9.53%
62.5%
-14.16%
Jan 2025
+17.66%
Oct 2023
n=107 · $S5TW + $S5FI + $S5TH + VIX + SPY all directly filtered · Jan 2007–2026
▸ VIX Spike Risk — Next 20 Days (from analog history)
VIX stays <30
66.4%
Fear subsides
VIX spikes >30
33.6%
More volatility
VIX spikes >35
20.6%
Panic territory
VIX spikes >40
6.5%
Capitulation zone
Analyst Note · 107 Direct Analogs (2007–2026)
This is a direct filter on all five indicators simultaneously — the most precise analog set possible. In historical periods where $S5TW, $S5FI, $S5TH, VIX, and SPY drawdown all matched, the market held within 3% in ~47% of cases and delivered a median 60-day forward return of +4.19%. The distribution is bimodal: this either resolves quickly or gets meaningfully worse, with little in between. Key watch level: VIX 35. Not investment advice. Past patterns do not guarantee future results.