StreetAlpha

Does trend following work on Bitcoin and Ethereum? A backtest since 2013

Crypto swings harder than almost anything else you can buy. We tested a trend following system on Bitcoin from mid 2013 and Ethereum from 2016: in the market when the trend is up, in cash when it is down, judged only on completed daily closes. Then we checked the most recent 18 months, which the rules never saw, separately.

PositiveAbout the same long run return as holding the coin, with a much smaller worst drop, and it held up in the 18 months we held back.
Bitcoin a year, vs holding82% vs 80%
Bitcoin worst drop, vs holding−74% vs −85%
Last 18 months, Bitcoin+3% vs −27%
Last 18 months, Ethereum+37% vs −20%

Most of the edge came from being out of the market during the big crypto crashes. The system was invested only about half of the time.

The rules we tested

  • Coins: Bitcoin from mid 2013 and Ethereum from 2016, daily closes, with a trading cost taken off every trade.
  • Signals: a trend reading built from long term moving averages and recent momentum, judged only on completed daily closes, never on moves during the day.
  • In the market when the trend is up, a small starter position when a beaten down market starts to turn, and cash when the trend is down. Leverage only in the strongest trends, and never over a weekend.
  • These are the rules our Crypto Quant bot trades, so we keep the exact settings private.
  • Judged against: simply buying and holding the coin over the same days.
Bitcoin trend system against holding Bitcoin: difference in yearly return by cycle (percentage points)
0%+21.00%2015-18−34.60%2019-21+12.00%2022-25

It lagged the 2019 to 2021 bull run, when being out after each dip cost more than the crashes it avoided.

Ethereum

On Ethereum the same system made about 101% a year against 92% for holding, and its worst drop was about 68% against 94%. Over the most recent 18 months it made about 37% while holding Ethereum lost about 20%.

What we added, and what we left out

  • Selling on big drops during the day: left out. It cut Bitcoin from about 79% a year to 49%, and Ethereum from about 88% to 33%. Most of those drops bounced, often in bull markets.
  • Buying a big one day jump off the bottom of a beaten down market: kept. It added about 3 points a year on Bitcoin and 13 on Ethereum, with a slightly smaller worst drop. It fires rarely, so we keep checking it. Buys like this in bear markets lost money, so it is not used there.
  • Rotating between Bitcoin and Ethereum, holding whichever was stronger: left out. It did far better in the last 18 months, but before that its worst drop grew from about 27% to 39%.
  • An earlier, half size entry before the trend confirms: left out. It helped Bitcoin in one cycle only and hurt Ethereum and the last 18 months.
  • Range trading in sideways markets: left out. It did worse in every period on both coins.

Altcoins

For altcoins we only hold a coin when both Bitcoin’s market and the coin’s own trend are up. Over the last 18 months that kept Solana and XRP about flat while holding them lost about 44% and 46%, and the worst drop was roughly half of holding the coin.

The most recent 18 months

The most recent 18 months, which we held back and checked separately, were a falling market for crypto. The trend system made about 3% on Bitcoin while holding Bitcoin lost about 27%, and about 37% on Ethereum while holding it lost about 20%. Its worst drop was about 19% on Bitcoin and 26% on Ethereum, against 53% and 68% for holding.

What it means for your trading

  • In crypto, avoiding the big crashes did more than catching every rally.
  • A trend system spends long stretches in cash. That is the system doing its job.
  • Selling on scary drops during the day hurt more than it helped: most of them bounced by the close.

Limits: daily closes since 2013 for Bitcoin and 2016 for Ethereum, about three full crypto cycles. The 18 months held back are a short test. Results include a simple trading cost but leave out taxes and other costs.

Where Bitcoin sits in its cycleThe Bitcoin Power Law chart shows today’s price against its long term trend.Open →

Crypto trend following questions

Does trend following work on Bitcoin?

In our backtest since mid 2013, a trend following system on daily closes made about 82% a year on Bitcoin against 80% for buying and holding, with a worst drop of about 74% against 85%. In the most recent 18 months it made about 3% while holding Bitcoin lost about 27%.

Is trend following better than holding Bitcoin?

It made about the same over the long run with smaller drops. It lagged in strong bull runs such as 2019 to 2021 and did best in crashes and bear markets.

Should you use a stop loss on Bitcoin?

Selling on big drops during the day hurt in our test: it cut Bitcoin from about 79% a year to 49%, because most of those drops bounced. Judging exits on the daily close worked better.

Backtest results are hypothetical. They are based on historical prices, include a simple trading cost and leave out taxes and other costs of real trading. Past results do not guarantee future returns. For informational and educational purposes only. Not investment advice, and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security.